Pioneer Press – Horner Lays out plan for slimming the budget

Posted by Jeff

Independence Party candidate Tom Horner offered a series of initiatives Thursday that he said would create jobs and revitalize local communities.

But Horner and his running mate, Jim Mulder, didn't put price tags on their broad-based mix of tax breaks and spending proposals, saying those would be worked out later.

At a St. Paul news conference, Horner outlined what he described as the first of a series of efforts aimed at turning around the fortunes of the state, which is looking at another multibillion-dollar budget deficit. Under questioning, he said he also would consider capping tax deductions that homeowners can claim.

Read More

Rob Hahn posts Budget Solution

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

  1. http://robbobforgov.com/Bold_Budget_Solutions.html

    REFORM

    Income Tax Reform

    New bracket for the über-rich
    Create a new 9 percent bracket for taxable income over $250,000 for a married couple filing jointly. This would raise approximately $468 million in the next biennium. This is merely one-half a percent more than the highest bracket was paying in 1998.1

    Capital gains tax reduction
    Reduce this tax to half its current level, when the gains result from long-term investments in Minnesota-based companies. This will encourage more people to consider investing in both existing, but more importantly in start-up companies, at a time when banks are not lending money freely like they once did.

    Corporate Tax Reform

    Cut and eliminate corporate income tax
    Make Minnesota really business-friendly. Cut the corporate income tax, currently 9.8%, in half and eliminate it entirely for businesses who invest 2.5% of their profits in PIE2 (Partners In Education – details of program to be announced later in July) and agree to certain parameters (i.e. purchase equipment from Minnesota dealers, make some investment in training and hiring unemployed, penalty for outsourcing or moving business out-of-state). This will encourage existing businesses to expand in Minnesota and allow them to pay better wages. Additionally, it will offer incentives for start-up companies to base themselves in Minnesota and help lure existing companies to Minnesota. More jobs mean more income tax. By investing in PIE, Minnesota businesses will help train and employ Minnesota students and recent graduates while simultaneously defraying their tuition costs.

    Get rid of loopholes and other needless protections
    · Close the loophole that allows companies to assign profits to a subsidiary in “tax haven” countries, essentially shielding it from taxation.
    · Discontinue the current Foreign Royalty exclusion, which exempts from taxation any income from when a multinational receives royalty payments from its foreign subsidiaries.
    · Repealing the special tax treatment of Foreign Operating Corporations (FOCs) and treat income earned from foreign sources the same as income produced domestically.
    It’s projected the savings from these reforms would raise $283 million.3



    REDESIGN

    Health Care - Switch to total cost of care model
    The focus of health care needs to be switched to health outcomes and not fees for services, according to the Bush Foundation. Under this plan, providers would decide on the cost of a year’s worth of services, and while teaming up with other sectors, essentially create a state portfolio of publicly paid health care. This is real health care reform, not just health coverage reform. The savings to the state would be $2.6 billion per biennium.5

    Provide health insurance subsidies, not health care services and payments
    Combine the four medical assistance programs for efficiency and provide an annual subsidy to a Health Savings Account (HSA). This has the potential to cover all currently uninsured Minnesotans, allowing them to purchase health insurance on the open market. The Legislature might need to remove the restriction for purchasing health insurance only within Minnesota. Projected savings is $2.85 billion per biennium.6

    Opt-in to Medicaid
    Capture federal dollars by “opting-in” to early expansion of Medicaid. Net benefit to the state over next biennium could be $1.2 billion.7

    Reform the Social Security Title IV-D program
    This would ensure that child support services are paid only to parents who qualify for public assistance. This is a component of Rob Hahn’s family law reform proposal. Estimated savings are $258.3 million per biennium.8

    Switch from county-delivered to region-delivered services
    Instead of 87 counties, there would be six regions to deliver services. By “combining funding streams, reducing administration costs and eliminating unnecessary rules, regulations, reports and advisory groups,” this reform will save an estimated $355 million per biennium.9

    Redefine state-county relationships
    Counties would be given more leeway by lifting levy limits and other property tax restrictions. Such changes would also make the counties more accountable to their citizens for money spent and services rendered. The state would provide a framework for as well as results expected from the property tax system and also work with counties to identify outcomes and associated dollars for services administered by the state but delivered by the counties. Approximately $267 million would be saved by redefining these relationships.10

    REVENUE
    (All figures, unless otherwise noted, are the total for a biennium)

    New Forms of Revenue

    Riverboat Gambling
    Legalizing state-sponsored riverboat gambling on waterways throughout the state would generate between $800 million to $1.2 billion per biennium with six boats in operation and create 3,000 jobs. Under the Hahn proposal, 50% would go to the General Fund, 20% to K-12, 20% to LGA and 10% to promoting tourism. There will also be a financial benefit (pre-tax formula) for host cities and counties not to mention the boon to their local hospitality businesses.11

    New tax bracket for über-rich
    By creating an additional tax bracket for families making $250,000 or more, it is projected the state would earn an additional $468 million per biennium in income tax collections.

    Fat Tax
    Place a tax on fast food restaurants (possibly 3-5%) and on soda pop (possibly a one-cent tax on every four ounces). Conservative estimates suggest this would take in approximately $100 million or more every two years, some of which will be used to offset the additional $1billion we Minnesotans pay in health care costs related to problems that result from obesity. 12

    Cut corporate loopholes
    By repealing three basic loopholes, which currently benefit some companies, the state would add $283 million to its coffers.

    New Revenue from Redesigns

    Health Care - Switch to total cost of care model
    The savings to the state would be $2.6 billion per biennium.

    Provide health insurance subsidies, not health care services and payments
    $2.85 billion

    Reform the Social Security Title IV-D program
    $258 million

    Switch from county-delivered to region-delivered services
    $355 million

    Redefine state-county Relationships
    $267 million would be save by redefining these relationships.


    Total Revenues from new sources and reform
    More than $6 Billion


    About The Proposal

    As sourcing indicates, we culled information from studies conducted by different groups from both the left, right and middle of the political spectrum. In addition, we also did our own in-depth analysis of various figures and proposals. Current revenue streams and other economic adjustments might affect some of the projected figures slightly. We provided these figures to third parties, who agreed most, if not all, figures provided in these proposals, though approximate, could theoretically be accurate. While the total amount of revenue generated from new sources and redesign of the system exceeds $8 billion, we’ve accounted for some loss of revenue that would result from the reforms to capital gains and corporate income tax reductions. However, the cut in corporate income tax will generate the creation of new jobs, which will increase the income tax base.

    The proposals are not absolute and most likely need some refining. But they represent a strong and innovative starting point to balance our budget and plan for the future. There are no short-term fixes in these proposals but rather long-term solutions.




    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------



    1 Minnesota Budget Project based on House Research.

    2 Rob Hahn For Governor PIE Initiative. Details to be unveiled separately.

    3 Ibid.

    5 The Bush Foundation, “Minnesota’s Bottom Line”

    6 The Minnesota Budget Solutions Coalition

    7 Minnesota Budget Project and others

    8 The Minnesota Budget Solutions Coalition

    9 The Bush Foundation, “Minnesota’s Bottom Line”

    10 The Bush Foundation, “Minnesota’s Bottom Line”

    11 Rob Hahn For Governor study and analysis

    12 Ibid.; Minnesota Health Department Study

Can't Buy me Votes ....

Posted by Jeff Labels:

A number of stories this week on the vast amounts of money being stock piled for the upcoming election season.

Bloomberg Businessweek

WCCO

Rob Hahn proposes Fat Tax

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Rob Hahn proposes a 3- to 5-percent tax on foods with high fat and high calories, and a 1-cent tax on four ounce soft drinks. (File)

It's not always healthy to eat, but is fast food bad enough to tax? That's what one Minnesota governor candidate wants to do.

This is one issue almost every Minnesotan will understand. Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Rob Hahn is proposing what he calls a "fat tax" on fast foods, soft drinks and even high calorie coffee drinks.

Read More

Mankato News on Tom Horner's Plan to keep Youth in communities

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

View it here

Star Tribune looks at Rob Hahn

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

People on their way to the office last Thursday couldn't help but notice Rob Hahn jogging through downtown Minneapolis in a black suit.

When you're an Independence Party gubernatorial candidate with no endorsement, no money and no name recognition, it's best not to be late when a law firm wants to learn more about your candidacy.

Read More

Interview with Steven Wilson in Pipestone County Star Newspaper

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

The Independence party has two seats in the U.S. Senate, but zero seats in the U.S. House.

Independence Party candidate Steven Wilson is hoping to breach that Republican/Democratic stronghold with his bid for Minnesota’s First Congressional District — a district that spans southern Minnesota from South Dakota to Wisconsin.

“We’re in the right place at the right time,” Wilson said. “I’m the independent voice that’s conservative and that I think 40 percent of the voters are looking for.”

Wilson, who received the endorsement from his party, is running against DFL incumbent Tim Walz; Republican candidate Randy Demmer; and Lars Johnson, a party-free candidate.


Read More

Survey USA – MN 6th Congressional District

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReport.aspx?g=37e41c98-7f52-4350-82b9-35876368de8b

Survey USA has released a new survey covering the Minnesota 6th Congressional District, in which Republican Michelle Bachmann is the incumbent and is running against Tarryl Clark (D), Bob Anderson (IP) and Aubrey Immelman (I).

The first thing which caught my eye in the results is that only 5% are listed as undecided. I actually noticed this before looking at the other numbers. This is an awfully low mark for this early in the season and while we are talking the 6th CD so it is possible that people have made up their mind whether or not they are voting for Bachmann it seems much too low.

The next thing that caught my eye was Bachmann's 48% and if the undecided seemed off, to me it clearly seems that Bachmann's numbers are also seem off. There are a couple of reasons for this, first the Democratic Party believes that Bachmann is vulnerable and a number like 48% doesn't equate to that possibility. Second, living in the 6th CD, albeit in a fairly "liberal" section if such a place exists, much of the discussion is on the millions both major candidates have amassed and when we start seeing the ads in full force.

When I look at Party Affiliation 36% Republican, 28% Democrat, and 31% Independent seems in line so it doesn't appear that the sample is tilted one way or the other.

Then of course I see how the results appear to be skewed in Bachmann's favor, 57% of the respondents own at least one fire arm. The largest number I have seen is around 42% for the state as Gun Owners tend to be more conservative that is a benefit for Bachmann. So while the rural 6th CD might have a slightly higher percentage of Gun Owners than the state average I doubt it is 15% higher.

So what do we do with these numbers?

There is little question that Bachmann is in the lead at the moment, the size of her lead in the election is probably smaller than the stated 9 percentage points. So at this point it something to watch.

What to Watch in upcoming polls?

The first thing to watch is the percentage of voters in the +/-50 age band. Currently the number of voters is 53% below age 50, the change in that number will be interesting, in the 6th CD I believe the more +50 voters there are as a percentage the better off it will be for Bachmann. In the latest numbers by the US Census bureau on age ranges only 15% of the population or 32% of the eligible voters. As these voters (especially in the more rural settings) a) tend to vote more often and b) tend to be more conservative in said situations. It will be interesting to watch.

The next thing to watch is percent undecided. I would have expected that number to be about 10% this early, but this is the 6th CD, if that number changes upward it will diminish the "trustworthyness" of this poll.

And finally percent Gun Owners. I thought this number was too high, a number closer to 47% would be more realistic for this CD.

What About Bob?

Bob is in a unique situation, I would expect Bob to draw around 10 to 12% in the general election, that number is going to be driven up or down by the actions of the Two Major Parties. If one or the other of the Two major Candidates has a major issue that number will increase, and if both parties go extremely negative (beyond the usual name calling) it could really drive his number up. It will really depend on how close to the election it happens.

Star Tribune looks at Tom Horner

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Introducing himself to 200 people at the India Association of Minnesota political forum in Bloomington, Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Tom Horner paused to take a swipe at the man seated next to him.

"It's good to see Rep. Emmer," Horner said drily of Republican endorsee Tom Emmer. "Some of us had forgotten what he looked like."


Read More

AP - Timid on taxes? Not in Minnesota governor's race

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

By BRIAN BAKST (AP) –

ST. PAUL, Minn. — One Minnesota governor hopeful framed his open concession to raise taxes as his "Walter Mondale moment." Another contender is fond of saying "Read my lips: Tax the rich" and makes a pro-tax pledge in TV ads. Two others don't shy either from tax calls.

At a time when the tea party and its had-enough message have politicians nationwide treading carefully, Minnesota's race stands out as a stark test of the public's appetite for government services versus a willingness to pay for them.

Voters will decide whether to veer left, a path that includes new taxes, or opt for another Republican vowing to rid the state of a budget deficit approaching $6 billion by attacking spending even more aggressively than departing GOP Gov. Tim Pawlenty did in his eight years. Pawlenty blocked nearly every tax increase, but Democrats say the state can't rely on spending cuts alone.

Read More

Ballot Access

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Minnesota has three ballot-qualified parties, all of which will choose their nominees on primary day, August 10. On July 2, TPT, a public television station in Minnesota, sponsored intra-party gubernatorial debates. See the one-hour broadcast here.

Read More

Mankato Press – Rob Hahn on Divorce changes.

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

MANKATO — Rob Hahn, an Independence Party candidate for governor, admits that divorce law is personal for him.

A father of two young boys, his divorce was finalized last year.

"It was probably at that time that I first gave serious consideration to running for governor," Hahn said during a stop in Mankato to promote his proposal to reform family law.

He describes his custody arrangement as not ideal but "pretty good." And since his divorce decree has been finalized, the proposed changes wouldn't affect him personally.

Read More

http://mankatofreepress.com/local/x1671040440/Hahn-looks-for-divorce-law-makeover

AP Reporting Large Scale spending against Tom Emmer

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Associated Press

The first substantial infusion of interest group money in the Minnesota governor's race is a half-million-dollar TV ad buy from a left-leaning group criticizing Republican Tom Emmer.

The Alliance for a Better Minnesota said Tuesday the ads would air statewide. The group said the spot dissects Emmer's voting record and compares the state legislator to Gov. Tim Pawlenty. A copy wasn't immediately available.

Past campaign reports show the alliance gets its money from labor unions, environmental groups and American Indian tribes.

Minnesota voters are expected to see plenty of advertising from groups not officially connected to candidates. That's because recent court rulings eased restrictions on how money could flow into the system.

A coalition of business groups says it too will be more active in the 2010 campaign than it has been in previous elections.

KSTP on Rob Hahn’s request for the IP to pull back endorsement

Posted by Jeff Labels: , , ,

KSTP

Independence Party Candidate for Governor, Rob Hahn, is asking his party to take back their endorsement of Tom Horner for Governor.

Hahn claims a recent poll conducted by Decision Resources Limited broke campaign ethics because the company is owned by Horner's deputy manager.

Hahn also claims the results were shared with Horner before they were released.

Those results gave Horner a stronger showing than previous polls.

READ MORE

http://kstp.com/news/stories/S1635339.shtml?cat=1

Rob Hahn on Tenure

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Grand Forks Herald

"Tenure a joke'"

Independence Party governor candidate Rob Hahn may not have won many friends when he said teacher "tenure is a joke" in an education forum mostly populated by a pretty liberal crowd.

"It is a license to be lazy and unproductive," he said at a forum whose main sponsor was the liberal think tank Growth and Justice.

Some quiet gasps were heard in the audience when Hahn said that.

The candidate said people may not agree with everything he says, but they will understand where he stands.

Read More

http://www.grandforksherald.com/event/article/id/167605/group/homepage/

Star Tribune – GOP Complaint Tossed

Posted by Jeff Labels: , , ,

Star Tribune

A judge dismissed a Republican Party complaint Thursday that alleged endorsed Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Tom Horner illegally profited from a poll he didn't pay for.

Despite the ruling, Independence Party gubernatorial challenger Rob Hahn called on Horner to withdraw from the race, saying Horner's involvement with the polling firm showed a lapse in judgment.

Read More

http://www.startribune.com/politics/state/97637464.html

Administrative Judge Dismisses Complaint against Horner’s Campaign

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Bill Salisbury – St. Paul Pioneer Press

An administrative law judge on Thursday dismissed a Minnesota Republican Party complaint against Tom Horner, the Independence Party-endorsed candidate for governor, for accepting what the GOP alleged were illegal corporate campaign contributions.
State Republican Chairman Tony Sutton said the party would appeal the ruling.
But Horner campaign manager Stephen Imholte said the ruling confirms that the Republican complaint was "bogus."

Read More

http://blogs.twincities.com/politics/2010/07/judge-dismisses-gop-complaint.html

Another Poll

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

KSTP/Survey USA Poll posted Here.

The Star Tribune posted some analysis of a latest poll, by KSTP/Survey USA.

Some Highlights, Matt Entenza has made an increase making it a three way race in the DFL Primary.

Tom Horner is at 12 %.

Horner - Sells remian Stock in Himle-Horner

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Article Here

Tom Horner - Statement on the U of MN Regents Advisory Committee

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Tom Horner's Statement.

U-M Regents dropped the ball in naming advisory committee to recommend next prez. Six professors on a 12-person committee? I'm calling for the regents to add business people (large and small employers); people from Greater MN who know
the challenges of our rural communities; and, experts on online education -- lifelong learning will be essential; we need people who understand how to make it happen.

There are two Higher Education institutions in the State of Minnesota, the University of Minnesota (U of M) and the Minnesota State College and University system (MNSCU) and while both of these great institutions provide for the Higher Education needs of the State, they have two greatly different prerogatives (for the lack of better term) on how that goal is to be achieved.

MNSCU is chartered or guided by the Legislature to provide the people of Minnesota with access to Higher Education, providing Technical Training, Certificates, Two Year and Four Year Degrees, and recently Advanced Degrees.

The U of MN is a Land Grant University with three distinct missions, regardless of how we feel about it General Higher Education is not among the three missions of the U of MN. Research, Education, and outreach are the stated goals of the U of MN.

To the average individual Education is Education, what separates MNSCU from the U of MN is the goal of education. MNSCU goal in education is to prepare individuals to fill needs in and of the State, while U of MN goal is more to prepare those people to for its other mission statements (Research and Outreach). In one of the greatest simplifications MNSCU is mandated to teach how to do something while the U of MN is mandated to teach to understand why we do something and to think about how to do that something better. Both of those ARE very great and important deeds and requirements of our society.

As both the U of MN and MNSCU are looking for new leaders, your statement is far truer about how MNSCU should look for its next Chancellor rather than the U of MN should look for its next President.
Online Education currently should be the purview of MNSCU; it fits their mission better than that of the U of MN. Small Employers, why what can they bring to the table for an organization that has a cyclical budget and employees tens of thousands of people. Arguing that the President of 3M should be included is one thing but Mom and Dad’s Convenience Store* is a whole different matter. Challenges of the Rural Community, what has that got to do with the University of Minnesota? Again I understand how systems work (butterfly wings in china = greatest snow storm in Minnesota history in August), but again they are better and more qualified people (than just being from Rural Minnesota).
Basically you are suggesting that I should be invited to sit on the Advisory Committee to Ford Motor Company simply because I drive a Ford Vehicle. In that case I just don’t bring enough to the table.

You also need to consider where the Money comes from, at MNSCU 1.3 Billion dollars of its 1.7 billion dollar budget comes from Tuition, Fees, and State Funding; on the other hand the University total budget of 1.7 Billion dollars 1.2 Billion dollars comes from Tuition Fees and State Funding, but there is a large addition to the U of MN Budget, Capital Expenditures, Self-Sustaining and Federal Funded projects are not included in that amount, neither are the budget of Fairview University Hospital. If you examine the total budget for the U of MN it receive as little as 41% of its budget from the State and that amount is getting less every year. If the current trend continues in the very near future, say 2016, the U of MN will receive less than 25% of its funding from the State. And People think the U of MN “thumbs it nose” now at State, wait until that point.

While I agree that the U of MN advisory committee should be broader, but not in the way you are thinking. There should be Provosts, College Presidents (emeritus), and other leaders from OTHER Large Land Grant Universities should represent the largest segment of the advisory committee. The problem is those individuals from other Institutions probably wouldn’t serve on the U’s committee. So the Regents set up a committee with the best that they can get.

*Please note my parents ran a small Convenience Store in the Vacation Country. So I understand the challenges of “small town rural Minnesota.” I go see it on a regular basis.

If you want to argue there is no reason anymore for Two Systems, or for Fairview University Hospital to be separate, or… Those are totally different arguments. Both President Brunnicks and Chancellor McCormick have stated that maybe it is time for the State to re-evaluate how these systems work.

So what did the Decision Resource LTD poll actually tell us?

Posted by Jeff

On the 7th the Pioneer Press published a poll by Decision Resource LTD that lead to a compliant (multiple complaints actually) by the GOP against the Horner Campaign. So what did we learn specifically about the election, the answer to those who don't watch politics close might be kind of shocking, nothing, or at least nothing about the actual election if you will accept that. We learn a little bit about the state of the people of Minnesota collectively, but the information released by the poll doesn't really tell us much new information on the election.

How is the poll different than the two earlier polls, first we don't get the demographic information (publically) that the two previous polls gave us, which is a key to understanding what the poll is telling us. Now I am told that information exists and people who pay Decision Resources LTD actually get to see it, but those of us on the sideline haven't or won't. As with the other polls, this is a first poll, a starting point for what polls in a few weeks look like, and that matters more.

This poll however is getting a lot more attention because of the complaint filed by the GOP. IS that a good or bad thing? For the GOP it is a relatively inexpensive way to attempt to discredit you opponent, if it works great if not the GOP hasn't really invested anything into it. Like others are saying the GOP knew they misfiled the compliant, and they did it intentionally. By misfiling the compliant they keep the credibility of the compliant in peoples' minds and more importantly they are attempting to keep the IP talking about how the information is in accurate as presented by the GOP, rather than focusing on fund raising and other strategic discussions. However there is more public backlash against the GOP this time around than actions like this have been in the past, something the GOP will need to keep in the back of their mind when the next issue pops up.

The GOP compliant I think also highlights how the GOP plans on running its campaign, or at least the negative part of the campaign. Between now and the Primary Emmer's team will be focusing on the Horner's campaign. After the Primary they will turn their attention to the winner of the DFL primary. Will the strategy work, my thoughts on that later.

Tom Horner's name is getting out there, but getting to 15% is the easy part, it's getting to 20%, 25% and 35% that is the hard part. The Horner's campaign ability to raise money will be tied to where the campaign is in terms of percentage; the higher the percentage grows the easier it will be to raise money. Think of it logarithmically rather than linearly. Say at 10% you can raise $100, at 15% you can raise $1000 and at 20% $5000 and at 33% you can raise $100000. Well those numbers are completely factious it does highlight how the system works.

The real key in these results are how some other numbers look. To me a couple of numbers standout, first the strong negative perception of Education Minnesota (and unions in general.) Unions as a whole have been seeing their membership decline and fewer union members obviously means less sway, you make up for this by going "statewide" with you union message. I think that Education Minnesota is stumbling over its own feet for the past few months, and this polls indicates I am not alone it message is achieve the opposite result. If that continues it may be bad thing to be endorsed by Education Minnesota and Unions in general.

Now I want to be clear I am not saying unions as a whole are bad, rather their message is being lost and they will be marginalized by their own accord.

Mankato Free Press - Tom Horner and the GOP

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

The Mankato Free Press published an article yesterday concerning the GOP current fasination with Tom Horner.

The state GOP has sent out seven press releases to The Free Press about IP
candidate Tom Horner since he officially kicked off his campaign for governor,
all of them attacking the former Republican and public relations firm executive.
The latest criticize Horner for not releasing his list of clients and for allegedly improperly receiving polling results before they were published.

Off-Subject – College Conference Re-alignment

Posted by Jeff Labels:

As many of you know I am a die-hard college sport fan(atic) between today and Friday there will be seismic realignment of big schools, probably the largest shift since the founding of the NCAA (and death of the NAIA).

My friends at the University of Texas tell me that the President of University of Texas, Powers Steering, informed the members of the Athletic Department that University of Nebraska is leaving the Big XII Conference and thus the Big XII Conference will cease to exist in or after 2012 school year. What's amazing about that, at least to me, is the Texas Christian University and University of Arkansas would like to join the Big 12, so even if the University of Missouri were to leave the Big XII Conference there are two geographically consistent major universities that would readily available. However there is little question that University of Texas feels that more money and easier access to it sports could be had in the Pac-10 than a reworked Big XII. Now however the politics of Texas come into play, will Baylor University be included in the move into the Pac-10 or will the University of Colorado. Baylor University has many alumni in powerful positions in Texas Government, not the Governor office at this time like when the Big XII was formed, but none the less people in position to make it extremely miserable for UT (and Texas Tech and Texas A&M) so my guess over the next few days we will see flexing of lots of political muscle in Baylor's regard.

It is widely assumed that University of Missouri and Rutgers University (State University of New Jersey) will also be in the Big Ten stable shortly. The question for the Big Ten is who will be the other two Universities to join the Big Ten, bringing the Big Ten to 16 Schools. Again it widely assumed that an invitation to apply will be offered to Notre Dame and another Big East school. I personally think University of Pittsburg would be a better fit, but others are suggesting Syracuse University or University of Connecticut. If Notre Dame decides not to accept the invitation all bets are off for the other schools, beyond Missouri and Rutgers. University of Maryland, United States Naval Academy, United States Military Academy (AKA West Point) (The Big Ten on AFN every week), Vanderbilt University, University of Tennessee (could you imagine Neyland Stadium in the Big Ten, I mean you could have 1.25 million fans at a Big Ten Football games on an early August Saturday) and the list of other suitors is indeed long.

I must assume we will have super conferences by the end of the next week, if not sooner. The Pac-16, the Big Ten. The Big XII will cease to exist, the Big East will also probably cease to exist. The University of Kansas, Kansas State University, Boise State University and maybe Colorado University will be off to join the Mountain West Conference and maybe two other schools making a 16 team conference (cough University of Nevada and Iowa State cough). The Western Athletic Conference (WAC) will need to find some new Division I schools (assuming the loss of Boise State and University of Nevada defection to MWC) which will be the hardest conference to fill. There just aren't enough Big Schools in the West to fill the bill (Texas El Paso?)

Conference USA will get several Big East Schools (three I think – Cincinnati University, Louisville University, and which ever school the Big Ten Doesn't take (Syracuse/Pittsburg) and the Two military academies USMA, USNA) to become a Super Conference (I should note the Two Military Academies would prefer to remain independent even more so than Notre Dame but probably will have no choice if they wish to remain FBS, leaving the ACC and SEC to decide what they want to do, again I assume super conferences of 16 schools. Who remains, West Virginia University, South Florida University, University of Connecticut, and the schools of the Sun Belt.

The ACC and the SEC must decide quickly or they will be left behind. The ACC may target the Military Academies, West Virginia and UConn which is a strong addition to the Conference; however the problem is the SEC, they are in the weakest position to expand, the Texas Schools have already spurned them, South Florida is not necessarily a sports power, so the conference to raid is the ACC, Florida State, University of Miami and a couple of others are nice, but those schools don't bring more TV sets into the conference realm… I think the SEC is in a word in trouble.

Okay enough ranting for a few hours.

Article on Bob Anderson

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Story on Bob Anderson on Hometownsource.com

Campaign Finance Board reject GOP Compliant

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

The Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board notified the GOP that it will not investigate the claim by the GOP the Horner's Campaign received an illegal corporate contribution. Gary Goldsmith, Director of the Board announced that the ruling is based in part because the Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board does not enforce or administer the law in question.

The GOP immediately announced they would refile their compliant with the Office of Administrative Hearings.

Is the GOP crying Wolf?

Posted by Jeff

Today to members of the GOP filed a formal complaint about a comment made yesterday on Twitter by the Horner Campaign, the question is "did the Horner Campaign gain inside information based upon Tom Horner's position and relationship with Decision Resources LTD?"

Several facts in the case stand for themselves.

  • The Horner Campaign received the results after they were released exclusively to the Pioneer Press.
  • The posting on Twitter was made almost 24 hours after the results were released to the Pioneer Press.
  • Any candidate could have requested the results from Decision Resources LTD.

With little question it "appears" that the GOP is crying wolf. Tom Emmer's minor bump in the polls thanks to the GOP convention is long gone and now his campaign knows they trail all three DFL candidates by a comfortable margin. Support for Horner continues to grow. Whether it is 12%, 15% or 18% is not the point but rather that Horner's percentage continues to grow is.

Members of the GOP file compliant against Horner’s campaign

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

They charge that the Horner Campaign received information from Decision Resources, LTD that no one else had.

Pioneer Press Story

KSTP Story

MPR Story

I must assume this is the posting in question from Twitter:

Must be bad Emmer poll coming. GOP stepping up attacks. Must be spinning their
candidate's collapse. Can we get a preview? How bad is it?

Posted at 2:09 PM on July 7th.



UPDATE
Release from the Horner Campaign
The Minnesota Republican Party is in full desperation mode. Their candidate is sinking, and instead of acknowledging their blunder in selecting an extremist candidate, they choose to go on the attack.

Minnesotans want more from their candidates this year. They want candidates who are addressing the issues of jobs, education and Minnesota's budget deficit. The survey is available to the Minnesota Republican Party. Perhaps they should use it to understand their candidate's shortcomings in the eyes of Minnesotans.

The Horner campaign learned last week of the survey being conducted by Decision Resources Ltd. Decision Resources was contacted by Stephen Imholte, campaign manager, who asked when the data might be available.

Imholte was informed that it was being released exclusively to the Pioneer Press on Sunday, June 6. Dr. Bill Morris provided the Horner campaign with data only after the survey information had been released to the newspaper. Before releasing information to the Horner campaign, Dr. Morris confirmed that the same data were being released to the Pioneer Press, and other campaigns and candidates at their request.

After the Pioneer Press news article was posted on the newspaper's web site, the Horner campaign released its own commentary on the findings through Twitter, Facebook and to other news media. It developed its analysis from the data provided by Decision Resources after release to the news media.

Decision Resources routinely conducts in-house surveys and occasionally releases findings to the news media. This survey covered a range of topics on Minnesota issues and the Minnesota gubernatorial race. The survey was not specific to any candidate but was a general overview of Minnesota issues. While the principals of Decision Resources are supporters of Tom Horner, the Horner campaign was not involved in any way in the design of the survey and had no knowledge of the findings until after its release to the news media.

If the Republican Party sincerely believed there was a violation, it would have asked for this background instead of wasting the time of the Minnesota Campaign and Finance Disclosure Board. Instead, the party of no ideas now also seems to have no campaign strategy or message for Minnesotans.

Poll by Decision Resources LTD, published in the Pioneer Press

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Another poll shows Independence Endorsed Candidate Tom Horner gaining in the polls. Decision Resources LTD of Minneapolis released a poll of 800 Minnesota adults to which Bill Salisbury of the St. Paul Pioneer Press wrote about here.

The Poll shows leads by all three DFL gubernatorial candidates over Republican Tom Emmer with Independence Party Candidate Tom Horner in third place with 15 to 18 percent of the vote.

When I get a little more time I will put some more analytical thinking into the numbers. But a couple of things caught my eye: 66% of the respondents thought Education Minnesota was more interested in protecting their paychecks than improving K-12 Education, only 21% of the respondents were against abortion and same-sex marriage (that has to be written incorrectly) and 53 percents believed the problem is not political parties but incumbants.

Back from Vacation

Posted by Jeff Labels:

After four quiet days of vacation I'm back: of course a lot happened in those four days.

  • Tom Horner had a "Mondale Moment"
  • A New poll was released
  • Dr. Maureen Reed withdrew for the Sixth District Congressional Race
  • Some interesting Articles about the DFL being in the spot light
  • More pressure on Tom Horner to disclose his Client List
  • Articles in several papers addressing what may be the hot button issues of the upcoming election cycle.

On a personal note I have been considering running for Office in a future election, but that's for another time.

Interesting Article in Today's Star Tribune.

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

In an widely circulated article Kevin Freking and Robin Hindery ask an incredible important question, is electability more important than ideology?

In Minnesota we have a similiar situation in the Sixth Congressional District with Michelle Bachmann and host ofothers running for her seat.

New Series of Links

Posted by Jeff Labels:

I have posted a list of web-links to candidates running under the IP banner on the left side.

This is by no way a complete list, but rather those that listed a web-site on their candidacy forms when the filed for office.

As more web-site become available they will be added to the list.

Additions or Corrections - email me at mnip-blog@hotmail.com

Amy E. Smith - Endorsed Candidate in Senate District 65

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

I would like to provide everyone with a link to Amy E. Smith's website.

Amy is the Endorsed Candidate for Senate in District 65, St. Paul. She is battling the incumbant Sandra L. Pappas (DFL) and Rick Karschnia (R).

Good Luck Amy!

Press Release - Jim Mulder

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Strengthening Minnesota Communities to be Focus of Lieutenant Governor Pick

MINNEAPOLIS and ST. PAUL, Minn., June 1 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Tom Horner, Independence Party Candidate for governor, today announced Jim Mulder as his choice for lieutenant governor. Horner said that Mulder's addition to the ticket reinforces his campaign's commitment to fix the budget, create jobs, and revitalize Minnesota communities. This partnership will end the "pass-the-buck" mentality that is forcing many school districts to go to four-day weeks, cities to cut public safety and communities around the state to struggle economically.

For the past 21 years, Mulder served as executive director of the Association of Minnesota Counties (AMC) where he led the administrative operations, legislative, and communications efforts that support Minnesota's 87 counties. During his tenure, he developed a comprehensive training program for member counties on managing change, revitalizing communities, and developing future leaders.

Mulder also worked as the county coordinator and chief operating officer for McLeod County. Early in his career, he worked for the House of Representatives in caucus research and as tax committee administrator conducting public policy research and analysis.

Horner said he sought three qualities in a lieutenant governor: "First, it is important that the lieutenant governor be a person of substance and experience, someone Minnesotans will trust as having the ability and skills to help lead the state through four years that will be extremely challenging.

"Second, given the scope of the challenges Minnesota faces, a lieutenant governor should have the ability to manage a key portfolio, one that will help define the state's future. There are few issues more important than redesigning the relationship between state and local governments. Traveling the state, you see how so many counties, communities and school districts are being pushed to the edge by pass-the-buck state policies.

"We need to create policies for where Minnesotans live, not where legislators work," said Horner.

"The third quality is a person who can help take this campaign to all 87 counties. While other candidates claim to have visited all 87 counties as part of a campaign, Jim has done it many times over as part of building a better state," said Horner.

Horner also pointed out that neither he nor Mulder have sought office before. "We are not politicians. We are people who have invested our careers in public policy, community service and business," said Horner. "We bring the perspective of people who aren't tied up in politics with the knowledge of those who know how government works and how to get things done."

Mulder said that for Minnesota to succeed, "We must have healthy, safe communities. That's where government puts the boots on the ground. Basic services such as clean water, police and fire, water treatment and so many more are what make each community flourish. A community cannot meet the healthy standard without healthy schools, healthy cities and towns and healthy counties. As part of the campaign, and as lieutenant governor, my role will be to listen to the concerns of local government elected officials. I will be the point of the spear for local government in the Horner-Mulder campaign and will be meeting with commissioners, mayors and city councilmen, town supervisors and school board members to share ideas and solutions to the challenges we face."

"In Jim Mulder, Minnesota has a candidate of substance, vision and innovation," said Horner. "I invited him to join the ticket because he is the best person for the job, not because of political considerations. In Jim Mulder, Minnesotans have insight into the high-quality people who will be invited to serve with me in my administration."

For more information regarding Horner's campaign and Jim Mulder, log on to www.Horner2010.com.

Prepared and Paid for Horner2010


SOURCE Horner2010

Back to top
RELATED LINKS
http://www.Horner2010.com

Horner chooses Jim Mulder

Posted by Jeff Labels: , , ,

Independence Party Endorsed candidate Tom Horner has selected Jim Mulder as his pick for Lieutenant Governor.


Jim Mulder is retired Minnesota County Association leader (an organization that represents all 87 counties) and is a strong indicator that Tom Horner is going to be focusing not only on the Twin Cities Metro Area but across the state with his campaign.


Hahn chooses Harens as his running mate

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

The Star Tribune is reporting that Rob Hahn has chosen Thomas Harens as his choice for Lieutenant Governor.

I had almost forgotten the Hahn was planning on continuing his bid after Tom Horner won the endorsement.

IP Night at the Saints! Strikeout the Wingnuts!

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Forwarded from the IP Party E-Mail
**********************************

Wingnuts...you know who they are. Pesky extremists who operate under the ruse of an elected official. They use their personal and party agendas to derail common sense legislation from the greater good.

And we're here to STRIKE'EM OUT!

Join the Independence Party as we watch the St. Paul Saints take on the Wichita Wingnuts on Saturday, June 26. Enjoy a pregame tailgating picnic and mingle with IP supporters and candidates, including the IP's endorsed candidate for governor and special guest, Tom Horner. We welcome everyone to this fun event - bring your family and friends and help us cheer on the Saints as we both try to strikeout Wingnuts!


St. Paul Saints vs. Wichita Wingnuts
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Midway Stadium, 1771 Energy Park Drive, St. Paul, MN 55108
Tailgating: 5:00 p.m. in Picnic Area D
Game: 7:05 p.m.
Contribution: $25 (includes pregame food and beverages and a reserved bleacher seat)

Order your tickets today on our secure, online website. Or you may RSVP to Sally Paulsen at salpaulsen@aol.com or call 651-628-9473. If paying by check, please make payment to: Independence Party of MN, and mail to: PO Box 40495, St. Paul, MN 55104. Seats are limited, so order right away!

We hope to see you at this great summer fun event!

Sally Paulsen, Treasurer
Independence Party of MN

Posted by Jeff Labels:

A Star Tribune Editorial by Gedney Tuttle that highlights the problem that we have in our current election system.

IP Trio to make it official at 1PM today

Posted by Jeff

It is my understanding that Steven Watson (First Congressional District), Bob Anderson (Sixth Congressional District) and Tim Olsen (Eighth Congressional District) will be holding joint news conference at 1PM today on the steps of the State Capital after they register for the upcoming elections.

Stay tuned.

Thoughts on Robyne Robinson

Posted by Jeff

Usually when people are talking about Lt. Governor Candidates it because they are political insiders weighing in on how the pick might sway the vote by a fraction of a point here or there. So when earlier this week when it was leaked that Matt Entenza was considering a retiring TV News anchor it caused a little stir in the media (especially the print media) and got everyone to thinking.

Now that the pick is official, what does it mean?

Of course the first official comments came from the Republican Party "Hail Mary pass" and "the latest sign of a desperate campaign" which is probably true in some cases, but there are several things to think of. Robinson is not the first local TV Anchor to go into politics, former Senator Rod Grams was also a TV Anchor, for the same station no less. Senator Grams was in his time one of the most conservative Republicans in the US Senate, I am reminded of the old saying "He who lives in glass house.." Next is most polls have any DFL candidate in a pretty much dead heat with Tom Emmer, this is not as if the campaign is 20 points behind and attempting to make up ground at the last moment. Considering how the Republicans chose Sarah what's her name..

Now Entenza is probably trailing the other candidates in the DFL primary, and yes Robinson is not your typical candidate, but I wouldn't compare her to a Hail Mary just yet. Matt Entenza has been out of politics since 2006 and while those of us who watch politics remember his name he has been out of sight and out of mind with the DFL party members this instantly gives his ticket name recognition. Who else could Matt have gotten, considering how long memories people in politics have what 'named' party member would take a chance on being on Matt's ticket.

This should bring in dollars and volunteers to Matt's campaign, not that he needs the dollars, but he will need plenty of volunteers to beat the other two on the ballot.

Tom Horner to announce his running mate on Tuesday

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

In little surprise, after the announcement of Robyne Robinson by Matt Entenza earlier today Tom Horner Campaign announced he would be making his pick public on Tuesday, June 1st.

It's official - Robyne Robinson is Matt Entenza Running Mate

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

It now official, Matt Entenza has selected long time TV Anchor Robyne Robinson to be his running mate. Check out press release here.

This of course throws a huge wrench int he works for the DFL. More on my thoughts later.

Rasmussen Reports – Governor Poll

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

On May 26th, Rasmussen Reports released its second Poll on Minnesota Governor and it reported a tossup, far closer race than reported by the MPR/Humphrey Poll of last week.

Emmer earns 38% support to 36% for Margaret Anderson Kelliher, speaker of the Minnesota House of Representatives. Horner gets 11% of the vote, and 15% are undecided.

If his opponent in former U.S. Senator Mark Dayton, Emmer picks up 37% to the Democrat's 35%. Horner trails with 12%, with 16% more still undecided.

By a modest 37% to 34% margin, Emmer bests Entenza, with Horner again at 12%. Seventeen percent (17%) remain undecided, given this match-up.

As someone who has watched polls for years there appears to be something wrong with the reported numbers. It's one of the burning things in the back of your brain that just doesn't seem to catch, so I decided to look at the methodology, of course it is one of those "learning" or "active" polls that takes a users response to determine the next question. Upon completion of the survey the computer decides who you are planning on voting for. For example if you are "anti-abortion" and live in Minnesota you will vote Republican, regardless of what else you think. Of Course this works so well in 2006 Rasmussen polls had Mike Hatch Leading 47 to 45 with Hutchinson at 7 percent using the same methodology in all the polls leading up to the 2006 election.

For the Independence Party there is plenty of good news in the poll, Tom Horner is at 11 to 12 percent. Relatively at the same time in 2006 Hutchinson was at 7 to 8 percent. Considering that Rasmussen is using the same methodology that should be construed as a good sign.

Dr. Maureen Reed files for 6th District Seat

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Four years ago Dr. Maureen Reed was the IP candidate for Lt. Governor on the Hutchinson ticket. Today she filed to run in the DFL primary against the DFL-endorsee Tarryl Clark in the 6th District where US Representative Michelle Bachmann is also seeking third term.

It is too bad an individual cannot vote in multiple primaries as I would vote for her, actually I might write her in on my ballot when I vote in the IP Primaries. I realize that Bob Anderson is the endorsed candidate in District 6, I however believe that Dr. Reed has the best opportunity to defeat Bachmann.

There are several reasons for this, first, the DFL has run extremely poor campaigns in the 6th District over the past four years. When your entire platform is "Beat Bachmann" that isn't going to win. Tarryl Clark has a more reasonable platform; however as a liberal leaning DFL member in a moderate to conservative district she isn't sitting in a position to pull the votes away from Bachmann, as evidence by Bob Anderson's shoe string campaign two years ago. To beat Bachmann you need to be a conservative leaning DFL or IP with the money to run a successful campaign, and it is the money that Bob doesn't have that stops his chances extremely cold.

How to Win the Governor’s Race

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

It's a common question, "Can the IP get another Governor Elected?" I am asked all the time, especially from my friends and family affiliations to other political parties. I have a usual tendency to nod, smile and give a look of derision. The simple answer is "yes, anyone who enters the race can win." Which usually leads to the follow up question, "How?"

And there you have asked the Sixty Four Thousand Dollar Question. How can a third party win in today's environment? To win you need a lot of things to go or at least lean your way, and not all of them have everything to do with your party and race.

You need the election to occur in an off year for federal elections. US Senators are elected for six year terms and are staggered so every 12 years this occurs. The last time it occurred was in 1998 and is occurring this year. The reason this is important is because the National Parties will spend millions on US Senator Elections and this spending enforces the two party system.

You need to have an election where the sitting governor is not running. This is a fairly common occurrence, but for the lay people it is really about the devil you know versus the one you don't. 1998 and 2002 this occurred and is occurring again this year.

There needs to be dissatisfaction with the sitting Government. This is something hard to measure, but if you look back to 1998 we had the Clinton/Lewinsky story as grabbing headlines all year. This created a strong dissatisfaction with the Government as a whole and polarized the two extremes of the major parties. In 2010 we have many issues polarizing the two extremes of the party. Health Care Reform, Wall Street Reform, disaster in the Gulf, two wars that the President inherited but cannot get out of, an economy in shambles, and the list goes on and on and on.

You notice that 1998 and 2010 have a lot of similarities, considering in 1998 Jesse Ventura Shocked the World in getting elected. The conditions are ripe for another win.

So the conditions are right, you ask "what else needs to happen?"

The third party needs to put up someone electable. I have spent some time talking to Tim Penny (2002) and Peter Hutchinson (2006) and a little time with Tom Horner (2010 Endorsed) and while it may seem callus Tom is a "more likable" guy. While Tim and Peter had many strong points, Tom is a better speaker off the cuff, has a stronger air of authority around him, and seems far more approachable than either Tim or Peter. In race with Tom Emmer and one of the DFL candidates Tom Horner is no worse than the second most likeable candidate. There is some question how he would fair against Mark Dayton, but he is well above the other two in terms of general likability.

Your candidate has to be well versed in the issues of the today and not carrying a large chunk of baggage with regard to those issues. That leads to the question, what are the issues, that another entry, but for now let's just say Tom Horner understands that Education, the Economy (Budget) and Government Services are the top three for everyone who isn't polarized by abortion, gay marriage, gun control, and separation of Church and State. Tom Emmer is polarized as far right leaning conservative, while Mark, Matt, and Margaret all have lots of baggage when dealing with the top three. Again if Tom Horner can capitalize on that he will be in great shape.

So that leaves two big issues, money and man power. The two major parties have access to both, however in this year there are things working against both parties. Without a Federal Election the amount of money spent by the national parties will be greatly diminished, almost non-existent in comparison to what both parties spent in 2006 and 2008. The Republican Party has chosen an extremely right conservative candidate in Tom Emmer (who people have stated makes Tim Pawlenty look like a moderate), while this energizes his conservative power base and gives him access to man power, money will be an issue in his party. Emmer will still have millions in his war chest, but compared to Tim Pawlenty's spending in 2006 think 1/3 to 1/2 less and remember everything costs 1/3 to ½ more this year; which is not good for Emmer. On the DFL side expect a bruising battle for the primary causing all three candidates to start emptying their war chest early and pre-bloodying the other candidates. In reality there are two out comes, as it stands today, Kelliher somehow manages to overcome Dayton, leaving her warchest broke and her reputation solidly bloodied, but with access to ample manpower or Dayton continues to win leaving him with a decent warchest but nowhere near the man power pool to work with; either solution is not good for DFL.

So now Horner needs to capitalize on those issues. He needs to spend enough money in advertizing and appearances to keep his name in everyone mind. This means lots of travel across the state, making speeches and hammer home the points.

Horner's campaign needs to build manpower, lots of manpower. While Horner will have the ability to raise money I think to be competitive the lack of a readily available manpower pool is what is going to be the greatest challenge to overcome. Jesse Ventura over came this in 1998 by appealing to the college aged students, something I think Tom Horner has to do. He needs to focus a goodly amount of time on the issues of higher education and he needs to mobilize those individuals.

Can Tom Horner Win, yes, everything is aligned to make a strong run, he has to capitalize on it, which is the question that remains to be answered.

Response from Larry Jacobs concerning MPR News and Humphrey Poll

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Jeff,

Thank you for the questions. I am traveling so my answers
will need to be abbreviated.

On the margin of error, this is a case
where knowing a little can get you in trouble. First, what everyone refers to as
"margin of error" relates to sampling error. This isn't a minor point because of
what we know about sampling. We never get 100% of our sample and therefore have
to weight and make other adjustments. The conventional margin of sampling error
for a sample of 701 is 3.7; we listed a margin of sampling error that built in
an adjustment for design error and therefore was 5.8. What we did is
statistically more accurate. Rather than being alarmed, consumers of polls
should feel more confidence owing to our caution.

I will say that I have
been impressed by the level of interest in some of the more technical issues and
will be expanding our "About the Survey" section that we attach to the end of
our poll reports. If you are interested, you can find it here --
http://www.hhh.umn.edu/centers/cspg/humphrey_polling/pdf/HHH_MPR_May_GovernorsRace.pdf


On party identification, the issue is how you handle "leaners" --
that is, folks who initially do not indicate a party preference but are then
asked a following about which party they lean toward. Research shows that the
leaners usually vote that direction. Coding the leaners with partisans is the
standard approach among survey researchers.

Take care,

LJ


Of course wasn't exactly what I asked...

After writing a entry on the poll conducted last week by the MPR News and
Humphrey Institute I was wondering if you would take a few moments to answers a
few questions concerning the results?
I should like to note that an answer
you provide will be share with my loyal readers, all four and ½ of them.

Under my presumptuous assumption that you would take a few moments I
have included my questions below.

Thank you very much for your time.
Very Respectfully
Jeffrey M. Johnson

Questions
Many of my
fellow bloggers have taken umbrage at the Margin of Error in the first poll and
have noted that many results sort of fall into within the margin of error. I
have noted that while there is a slim chance for results like Dayton’s ten point
lead over Kelliher could be reversed the reality of these polls is they are
better at tracking trends than giving exact numbers. We look to follow on Polls
to monitor if Dayton’s lead is decreasing, staying the same, or increasing.
How often is MPR News and the Humphrey Institute planning on running similar
polls to this one?
Are you planning to revamp your Poll before the next one
is conducted to address the criticism of the first poll? Would any changed
effect the validity of the first poll?

In the first poll there were
three things that caught my attention; the poor showing of Matt Entenza, the
high number of Undecided/Refused/Other, and the extremely high number of people
who identified with a Party Affiliation.

Under the auspices that Matt
Entenza is going to make a strong effort to move his campaign forward I have
noted that were he pulls his support from as the Primary Election gets closer
will go a long way to determine the winner. Would you agree that if he starts
pulling votes primarily from the undecided pool of voters than that goes a long
way to help Dayton’s Campaign?
I am under the current belief that today
Kelliher really needs an active Entenza in the primaries to defeat Dayton under
the guise the Entenza/Dayton should spilt the so called unhappy voters. Would
you agree that is the key trend to watch in the DFL primaries?

As
polarized as this election appears to be watching most media reports were you
surprised to see such a large pool of undecided voters?

Party
identification in the State of Minnesota has historically been in the high
twenties to mid thirties in the past decade or so, what would you attribute such
a large growth in these numbers over the past year?

While not mentioned
specifically in your first release, how much support do you find out there for
third parties, not just the IP, but other parties like Libertarians, Green, and
so on? I had felt going into this year’s elections this would be the break out
year for smaller parties, primarily at a state level, but that swelling movement
seems to have greatly dissipated as we moved forward this year. On a personal
note I am very disheartened to already be hearing “wait until 2012” from people
in these small parties. What do you think end their movement so early this year?

Robyne Robinson for LT. Gov.

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Media Reports this afternoon are suggesting the Robyne Robinsin, the former KMSP Channel 9 news anchor has been asked to be Matt Entenza running mate in the elections.

My how the quiet little election just got "weird" in a heart beat.

Robyne does not bring "politics" to the voters, but she does bring name recognition, which is what Matt Entenza is missing in his (at least in comparison to the other two canidates) so this is something that will have to be watched. Is it a home-run - or a lazy fly ball is yet to be determined.

EDIT - I have been reminded that News Anchors are allowed in the politcal arena if Robyne is off the air-tonight, we may know more than we think we know.

St. Paul Pioneer Press - Emmer vs. Others

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

The St. Paul Pioneer Press Article on the Federal Medicaid Health Care Program.

"I absolutely would exercise the option. This is another example of Tom Emmer and other Republicans cutting off their noses to spite Minnesota's face," said Independence Party endorsee Tom Horner, a former Republican. "This is the way to transform health care."

My opinion on healthcare remains unchanged. Obama's plan is an expensive but very very small first step, if we as a society not ready to continue making steps and changes to improve the American Health Care system than it was wasted money.

A statement from Mark Dayton that I could not agree more with "Their [Republicans] only hope is to nationalize the (state) election and run against President Obama," Dayton said. "That's where their anti-government theme gets the most traction."

Star Tribune - Hopefuls looking for $6 Billion

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

A Minneapolis Star Tibune Article highlights how the leading canidates for Governor in this falls elections.

There are lots of comments posted from readers but I think the article highlights what many of us already know, so far only Tom Horner has talked about long term solutions.

Mark Dayton’s Pick

Posted by Jeff

As many of you know, I believe that Tom Horner's Best chance of victory comes in a match between Margaret Anderson Kelliher and Tom Emmer so lately I have been semi-disheartened by the DFL party. First you have Kelliher selecting a moderate Republican John Gunyou, a virtual unknown outside of tight government circles and then this morning Mark Dayton is preparing to announce Yvonne Prettner Solon, a DFL State Senator from Duluth. There is little question that Mark Dayton's selection will benefit him in the polls come the August Primary.

While I can't personally give you details on Solon, she is the sitting state senator from Duluth, an extremely fundamental DFL stronghold in northern Minnesota which has an solid reputation for participating in caucuses, primaries, and the general election. This is arguably the strongest step that Mark Dayton has taken thus far to secure the Primary win. I'm betting there has to be a lot of finger-pointing and gnashing of teeth in the Kelliher/Gunyou HQ this morning. Which undoubtedly is probably matched in the Horner and Emmer camps.

Star Tribune Article

Who?

Posted by Jeff

Margaret Anderson Kelliher needed to make a huge splash, RT Rybac, would have been a big splash, and would have worked wonders in the polls, now everyone is going who? However when the headlines read "Democratic gubernatorial candidate Margaret Anderson Kelliher picked former state Finance Commissioner John Gunyou as her running mate on Friday." You got to be left scratching your head.

I was and still am dumbfounded that Margaret Anderson Kelliher would select such a unknown as her running mate, well at least unknown to 90 plus percent of the potential voters when she was in a such a tight, okay not so tight she is well behind Dayton in the polls.

Here is a case where someone isn't paying enough attention to the race. The idea of bringing on a moderate republican leaning candidate would work, if she wasn't in a battle in the Primaries and there wasn't that pesky little Independence party to deal with. I mean considering how right of center Emmer is in a two party race you could sure stand to pull off a good chunk of Moderate Republicans who are more socially liberal than Emmer, but that isn't the case.

I have to believe this of course hurts the Tom Horner and the Independence Party chances in the General Elections because if Margaret Anderson Kelliher doesn't win the primary, Mark Dayton will thrive in the center, right where the Independence Party wants to live. I am reminded of the elections of Arne Carlson, where he was not the endorsed candidate.

HHH Poll

Posted by Jeff

Our friends at Humphrey Institute released the first of many Independent polls we will see between now and Election Day.

As many bloggers are going to be vigorously discussing over the next few days this first poll has a whooping Margin of error of 5.8%. Considering that most polls have a margin of error under 4% that 5.8% is nearly 40% greater than what pollsters are typically looking for. I am sure there are a number of factors involved in getting such a large margin of error, for example it is early in the campaign season with no national or federal elections in the state. While all that is interesting (hey six quarters of statistics are worth something) it not really the point.

In looking at the details Mark Dayton is leading the DFL primary race, comfortable with 10 percentage point lead. I can hear the calls now "you just said the Margin of Error was a whopping 5.8%, isn't that 10 point lead within the margin of error?" Yes, it is, however you have to understand how margin of error works and levels of certainty. Long story short they further you deviate from the result the less likely it is accurate. So while Dayton's is leading at 38% the likelihood of his polling numbers being 32% is virtually nil (statistically speaking about .001 percent chance, I haven't dealt with a poll with such a large sampling error in a while so my math might be a bit rusty). The flip side of that is true also for Margaret Anderson Kelliher in getting to 32%. So there is a .00001 percent chance that Margaret Anderson Kelliher leads. If we look at the lead from the poll it is easy to say 6 to 14 percentage point lead, which is to say a comfortable lead.

Was Professor correct in saying the results were "a slap in the face" to the DFL, yes and no. First the reality is that fresh of the endorsement, just out of the gate and the fact that Margaret Anderson Kelliher is on the campaign trail and in the news it's really a slap in the face to the democratic party because a swing as much of seven points or bounce is usually anticipated, so things are not looking good for the establishment. However it is really not a nice thing to say, especially when you have such a large margin of error.

The real key however is Matt Entenza's extremely low polling number. This is the number people are going to have to watch. Under current circumstances Margaret Anderson Kelliher needs a three person race if she is expecting to compete the more Matt Entenza becomes a non-factor the more difficult it will be for Margaret Anderson Kelliher to win the primary. Too many people are ousting the sitting politicians right now, and how poorly she performed (there is no way to sugar coat that one) in office leading up to the end of the session she has painted a huge target on herself. The way to nullify that is to split the anti-establishment vote, yes I realize that neither Matt Entenza or Mark Dayton are unknown in politics, but they were sitting at the desk when Governor Pawlenty drove all over them. If Entenza is going to make a run he has to start drawing votes, it is where he draws the votes from that will be important, if he pulls votes from Dayton than it is good for Kelliher, if he pulls from the Undecided (which is 25%) than it is good for Dayton. Entenza has the money, does he decide to use it will be the question.

The second question is where does everyone sit in terms of the general election. Dayton leads Emmer and Horner, Emmer leads Kelliher and Horner. Again more bad signs for the DFL. Not necessarily the numbers but where the vote is coming from; in this case Emmer loses about 17% of the Republican vote to Horner (6 percent of the overall vote) but right now only 10% of the Democratic vote is going to Horner, that number is historically higher and taking historical precedent into play with Horner could end up with 15% of the total vote without spending a dime. If Horner runs a well crafted campaign he looking to pull in the 20% range easily, especially if it is Emmer v. Kelliher.

As a final point I found it either disheartening or concerning the percentage of people who identified themselves with both political parties, identical 42%. The first concern is that 42% is an awfully big number, considering a year ago those numbers were in the low to mid twenties. That an impressive doubling in a year. That in itself calls more question into this poll than any other factor, however it could be summed up on whether or not the individual was going to vote in the primary, the more you ally yourself with a party the more likely you will vote in the primary, so that could be it, but we will have to watch and see.

Horner on Education

Posted by Jeff

Tom's position on education can be found here: http://www.horner2010.com/issues/education/

When I read this statement, I have to be honest, it's a lot of fluff that doesn't say anything and I think highlights the problem in Public Education in Minnesota and across the country.

About half of all Minnesota students – students from every community and from every background – are entering kindergarten unprepared to learn.

I am an upper-middle class, two income family, where both my wife and I have College Degrees. We have a five year old son who enrolled in Kindergarten this year. My son, who is without question above average in intelligence and has no physical or mental handicaps was not prepared learn when he entered Kindergarten. Not even close. My wife and I spent months playing catch up with our son getting him to "what's expected" at his age in the current system. The problem isn't that my son wasn't prepared for Kindergarten; the problem is we as parents weren't prepared. We need to get parents involved and prepared to learn six months or more before school start. Handouts when we register our child indicating what is expected, learning about how punishment, rewards, and other activities work is more important than ever. Had we had an inclination our son would have been prepared for Kindergarten.

Meanwhile, high school graduation rates among many of our fastest growing populations are dropping below 60 percent. At a time when our economy demands more college graduates, a falling high school graduation rate is an economic crisis that will affect everyone.

High School graduation rates are dropping in all sectors of the population, to me the biggest reason is what is expected of people upon graduation. People drop out cause there is no benefit to be there. Start talking to the dropouts and ask them specifically why.. "I'm not going to get into College, so to me the difference between $9 an hour at the Fast food place and $10 at gas station as an assistant manger…." You need to put reason into High School for those that see it as an end, rather than a beginning.

We should pay good teachers salaries that compete with jobs in private business.

The average Full Time teacher in Minnesota earns $47,000, the average salary for a college graduate is $58,000. However that isn't the full story the average teacher in Minnesota total compensation package is closer to $70,000 a year while the average college graduate is under $67,000. So we already compensate our teachers at a higher rate than those with a college degree, when you factor in Retirement, Health Care, and other benefits. That is not the issue. The real issue is the starting point, when you become a teacher today, expect to start well below your fellow graduates on the pay scale and bounce around between jobs/districts until you have enough time/tenure/experience to get the job you really want.

For too long, policy leaders have sat silent while the value of education is denigrated. We need to make investments in making sure that all parents have the tools to help their children succeed in school, then hold families and students accountable.

Great sound bite, but how? Parents are spending more hours at work, children spend more time with babysitters/child care/teachers than the parents, how are you going to keep parents accountable. Parents can't even return forms to schools.

And, we need to hold school districts accountable. Resources need to go first and foremost into the classroom. We need to work with the innovative programs that are adapting new ways of learning to today's students. And, we need to invest in technology, not as a replacement for face-to-face interaction with classroom teachers, but as a complement.

The problem isn't the classroom, that's why we keep going round and round on the problem. The problem is today's children have nothing to do outside of the classroom, except stare at the TV and play Video games.

We really need to focus on putting play in education, learning about things outside of textbooks. Keeping our children in better shape mentally and physically.

We need to focus our efforts on keeping children from bouncing between daycare in the morning, full day school, and then back to day care. Lets develop programs where children go to school in the morning and our there the entire day, rather than bouncing between two three four services. That doesn't mean classroom time, but other activities, band, organized sports, science.

The opportunities for improvement are endless and we need to look at every option to improve education.

Our high school graduates need to be more prepared to directly enter the work force, it not a college prep-school.

We need to become more bi-lingual, whether it is Icelandic or Arabic. In a global economy communication skills are what will separate our children from those in other states and allow them to get further ahead.

Tom Horner for Governor, can he win?

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Many people know my preference for the Independence Party over both the Democratic and Republican Party so when I am asked “Now that Tom Horner has been endorsed can he win?” I really had to think about the answer.

The first aspect of the question is who will be running in the other parties.
We are fairly certain that Tom Emmer will be the candidate for the Republican Party. On the democratic side it gets a little, okay a lot murky. Margaret Anderson Kelliher has been endorsed but she will face two well better known and arguable better financed candidates in the Primary.

If we focus on Tom Emmer for a second we know he is an “extreme” conservative that outside of the Republican Party is not well known. I have been told he make Tim Pawlenty look like a liberal when it comes to both his social and economic outlook. He is the type of candidate the TEA party love. Someone who claims they will cut their taxes by cutting Government Spending. Anyone with an Eighth Grade Public Education knows that is not possible, but it is that believe that is important for Emmer. The problem for Emmer is the ultra conservatives may give him a fairly large and willing volunteer cadre, it doesn’t really open up his check book for spending since the TEA party supporters tend to not have as deep of pockets as the business people who also form another side of the Republican Party.

If we move to look at the Democratic Ticket we see chaos theory in action. Margaret Anderson Kelliher is endorsed, in the DFL political circles she is well known, well liked and well regarded. The problem is the Political circle is such a small portion of the Electrorate as she will need to get support in the Primary. In the Primary she will face Mark Dayton, a name every Minnesotan knows and deep deep personal pockets and Matt Entenza, a name that not every Minnesotan knows with very deep deep pockets. Personally I think the race will come down to Dayton and Anderson Kelliher, but there is another wildcard. With so little riding on the Republican Ticket will Republicans vote Democrat in the Primaries too choose a candidate they think is easier to defeat in the General Election. In the end I think Dayton’s name recognition and personal wealth get him selected in the Primary.

With whatever the result of the Democratic Primaries the candidate will emerge extremely bruised and even worse having spent a substantial amount of their war chest to get that far. That plays into Emmer’s hand.

Let us assume that Tom Horner gets through the Primaries without having to spend a small fortune just to get selected as the Independence Party (he is not unopposed). What will have in the General Election.

20 to 25% of Minnesota will vote Democratic, 25% Republican, and 10% Independence Party just because that is what they those people always vote. That leaves 40% of the electorate up for grabs. This is not a race for the 51% but rather a race for the most votes. So the question is how will those 40% of Minnesotans vote.

The Democrats have several problems, starting with the backlash of the “failure” of Obama to dramatically change course of the Federal Government. No arguably the course of the Federal Government was set under President Eisenhower and everyone since just attempts to keep the ship on course, but that back lash of the perceived failure hurts the Party. The next issue is the Party is not united. If Margaret Anderson Kelliher wins the primary she will shift the party’s focus further to the left if Dayton or Entenza win the party will be more moderate. Either way 5% of the party vote (that 20 to 25%) is gone. With Dayton running look for a strong showing by the Green Party, with Margaret Anderson Kelliher a strong showing by the Independence Party. It behooves the Independence Party to see Margaret Anderson Kelliher win.

The real key is how is Emmer perceived by the general electorate. The more he is painted as a Right Wing fanatic the more the moderate Republican and centralist independent vote is needed. The democratic party, league of cities, and the Unions this year have unfettered spending to attack his campaign, he will be painted even further right (which is hard to imagine) than he really is.

So my assumption is Margaret Anderson Kelliher is the DFL Candidate and Tom Emmer is the Republican Candidate, if that is the case you are looking at fairly left of center candidate, a moderate republican, and conservative republican candidate running for office. It in many ways is a perfect storm, the total opposite of 1998 where three centralists split the vote and Jesse Ventura was elected.

If the Two parties attack one another early and often, watch for Tom Horner’s poll numbers to rise slightly. If that happens watch the two other candidates start attacking his positions, the moment that happens Tom Horner has a chance, the earlier that happens the better chance that Horner will have. If both Emmer and Margaret Anderson Kelliher are attacking each other and Horner by Mid-August that 40% may break in Horner’s favor. Pulling 5% off either party plus pulling 15% (37% of the undecided vote) Tom Horner will be the next Governor. While we know that Tom Horner can win we should know early how likely the chance will be that he does win.

Video from the Convention

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Tom Horner Speech
Jim Koepke Speech
Chris Pfeifer Speech

Announcement of First Ballot
Tom Horner Victory Speech
Tom Horner Press Conference

I will post more as I find it.

Tom Horner Endorsed

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,

Tom Horner has been endorsed by the Independence Party of Minnesota for the upcoming Election.

Links
Story on Minnesota Public Radio
Minneapolis Star Tribune
St. Paul Pioneer Press

A Look at the four Challengers for Endorsement

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Tom Horner: A Public Relations Executive with experience in Political circles, albeit Republican circles where he served under US Senator Dave Durenberger.

Rob Hahn: A Regional newspaper publisher and former Radio Producer with little political experience.

John Uldrich: Founder of International Market Firm with limited political experience.

Chris Pfeifer: A Party Activist with limited experience.

Jim Koepke: I wish I could tell you more.

Survey USA says....

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

Republicans appear posied to hold state house.
In a match-up against
Democrat House of Representatives Speaker Margaret Anderson Kelliher, Emmer, a
MN House member first elected in 2004, today gets 41%, Kelliher 33%.
Independence Party candidate Tom Horner gets 9%; 17% of likely voters are
undecided.
Survey USA uses a RDD system that may or may not include cell-phone only households. The one issue I have with Survey USA is they artificial weight respondents if they don't get a nessecary percentage from a zone. In this case the Republicans in outstate would typically be given a small bump because they are more likely to have land lines and have the lowests response rate. Whether that is accurate or not is another story.

The Supreme Court Unallotment Ruling

Posted by Jeff

Today the Minnesota Supreme Court Rules that Governor Tim Pawlenty overstepped his Authority by unalloting 2.7 Billion Dollars in the current budget. Of course the ruling will be misinterpreted by those on both sides of the fence.

The Minnesota Supreme Court did not rule that unallotment was unconstitutional, although two members questioned that as well, rather they ruled in this specific case the Governor created the shortfall thus cannot use the unallotment powers to reduce funds. Thus the powers of unallotment cannot be both a sword and shield.

Unallotment is a shield, if an unanticipated financial shortfall occurs while the Legislature is not in session the Governor can unallot money to allow the Government to stay afloat. However it is not a sword that can be used to dictate terms to the Legislature.

The real concern is that the Governor and the Legislature will most likely argue in the press and do little to resolve the issue, of eliminating the anticipated debt.

The Current and Future...

Posted by Jeff

As promised…

Several weeks ago I indicated that I would post my opinions of the position of the Independence Party and how the campaigns were run.

Filed under “If I knew than what I know now”
I was a delegate at the Independence Party State Convention way back in June..
I should have supported Jim Haviland for US Senate rather than Robert Fitzgerald and I think the party would have been better off if more people would have done so. That is not to say that I think Jim Haviland would have been a better candidate rather it would have freed up Robert to run for different office.
I never thought even in my wildest dreams that Robert Fitzgerald would have even the slightest chance of winning in this election. I think several things were working against him, okay 25 Million things were working against him, but other problems also were against him; Age Experience and okay Money. If Robert would have been say a State Senator than suddenly rather than say 3% he could have drawn 11% or better; it’s all about developing the party’s future.

Filed under “I just wish he was more likeable”
I think the Minneapolis Star Tribune Endorsement of Mike Hatch summed it up best. “But winning the office and succeeding once there require an ability to sell ideas, build broad support, assemble allies in the Legislature and mobilize voters -- all things that Hutchinson and the weak IP have thus far failed to do.”
I honestly believe that Tim Penny and Peter Hutchinson are two of the most intelligent men I have ever met when it comes to Governmental Financing, however neither was most personable people, not that they didn’t try mind you.
Looking forward to the future if I had to choose a Lt. Governor Candidate either one would be great choice, as long as you can find a very personable Governor Candidate.

To be Continued

Election Coverage

Posted by Jeff

You know it is bad coverage when *I* decide to watch a repeat of poker on ESPN instead of election news.

ABC - Where did they find these people?
CBS - Kouric wasn't too bad but everyone she talked to seemed to want to be somewhere else.
CNN - Interesting Graphics, but way too many people were talking and no one seemed to be "in charge".
FOX - I guess it was just a really bad day to be a republician, or republician supporter.
NBC - Did they have election coverage? On a local side they weren't too bad, except showing all of Senator Elect Klobuchar speech.

Predictions for Tonight.

Posted by Jeff

Okay Jeff's Predicitions

Governor
Pawlentey - 43%
Hatch - 42%
Hutchinson - 14%
Other - 1%

Senate
Klobachar - 51%
Kennedy - 40 %
Fitzgerald - 8%
Other - 1%

US House 1
Gutknecht defeats
Walz

US House 2
Kline defeats
Rowley

US House 3
Ramstad defeats
Wilde

US House 4
McCollumn defeats
Sium

US House 5
Ellison - 41%
Lee - 35%
Fine - 22%
Other - 2%

US House 6
Wetterling - 46%
Bachmann - 46%
Binkowski - 8%

US House 7
Peterson defeats
Barrett

US House 8
Oberstar defeats
Grams

Exclusion of Robert Fitzgerald from the MNN/MFN US Senate Candidate Debate.

Posted by Jeff

I have been informed that the Minnesota News Network / Minnesota Farm Network has decided to exclude Independence Party Candidate Robert Fitzgerald from thier US Senate Candidate debate on November 2 in Rochester.

One must wonder where such exclusionary and arbitrary practices are supposed to accomplish. Democracy is built upon the foundation that the voters are given the opportunity to make the best choice in their personal opinion. Suppressing the opinions of any candidate diminishes democracy suppressing the opinions and views of a Major Party Candidate are unheard of, unless you believe the rhetoric put forth by some in the other Major parties.

Three weeks ago, they set an arbitrary 10% polling threshold as a requirement for inclusion and all of our appeals have failed. This is despite the following facts/conventional precedents:

· On 9/1/06, Robert’s opponents Amy Klobuchar and Mark Kennedy conceded that Robert should be included in all debates.

· The threshold for major party status is 5% of the vote in a statewide race.

· Most other media outlets use either a 5% polling threshold or a major party status standard. Robert has met both of these (the only exceptions are Minnesota Public Radio which only uses major party status and Debate Minnesota which only uses a 5% polling threshold both included Robert).

· Robert has easily exceeded the 5% threshold in numerous polls reaching a high of 9% despite marginal media coverage.

· The Independence Party of Minnesota has maintained Major Party Status since 1994 and is on solid ground to continue that through 2008 at the very least.

Jeff

Back Sort Of...

Posted by Jeff

It’s been a tough summer in the Johnson Household. Three separate major medical emergencies have hit home, involving my wife, my mother and myself. It surprising where time goes when not so great things are happening in your personal life.

While I am not going to have the time to make this blog extremely active over the next couple of weeks, I am going to post some of my views.

Jeff

S much to do so little time

Posted by Jeff

I'll get some more posts up later this week. With work and my other job I been really busy.

I have some interesting thoughts on the CD5

Jeff

MySpace

Posted by Jeff

Below are the links to Robert's, Tammy's, and John's myspace web-pages:

Robert:
http://www.myspace.com/votefitzgerald

Tammy:
http://www.myspace.com/tammyleeforcongress

John:
http://www.myspace.com/johnforcongress

An Inpendence Party Group:
http://groups.myspace.com/IndepencePartyofMinnesota

Stephen Williams's decision to run in the primary election.

Posted by Jeff

I spent several evening attempting to confirm that Stephen Williams had decided to run in the September Primary. Unfortunately I must rely on a news report which says he is.

At the IP State Convention Stephen only mustered 14 votes on the first ballot out of 250 plus votes, which is about 5%. So I must say I am perplexed by Stephen’s choice, I doubt he can get too many more votes in the Primary than he got in the State Convention. His chance is probably so small that Robert Fitzgerald will completely ignore him and concentrate on the General Election.

This is a completely different case than Ford Bell’s decision to run against Klobuchar in the Primary for the DFL nod. Ford decided he could not muster the votes at the state convention to win the nomination and rather than creating in-fighting and dissention at the DFL state convention by not attending.
Ford Bell has raised between three quarters of a million and one million Dollars to support his candidacy. This is a substantial amount to which he can use the entire amount before the Primary which can not be done by Klobuchar. She must plan on the big fight before the federal election.